The worst redesigns are rarely the ugly ones. They are the changes a company paid for to make its product better, with designers, data and a launch plan, that ended with the company apologising to its own customers: a CEO’s open letter, a petition with 1.2 million signatures, a logo withdrawn after a week. This list runs from Facebook in 2006 to Sonos in 2024, each case with its date, what changed and what it cost as reported at the time. One is packaging rather than software, one was never reversed, and one turned out to be right. After the list come the reasons redesigns fail, in the companies’ own words where they gave them, and what a safer redesign does differently. All sources were checked on 4 November 2026.
— Top
The worst redesigns: Sonos, Snapchat, Digg and six more, and what they cost
Nine companies paid to make a product better, and most of them ended up apologising to the people who used it. Dates, figures and outcomes, from Facebook in 2006 to Sonos in 2024, and what the failures have in common.
Nine redesigns and rebrands that users pushed back on, 2006–2024
| Company | Year | What changed | What happened | Cost / impact as reported |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 | News Feed added | Petition of 500,000+; apology within days | Kept, with new privacy controls | |
| Tropicana | 2009 | Juice carton (packaging, not a website) | Old carton back at end of February | Unit sales down 20%; est. $27 million |
| Digg | 2010 | Version 4, a full rebuild | Users protested and moved to Reddit | US visits down 26% in a month |
| Gap | 2010 | New logo | Old logo back after about a week | Not disclosed |
| Skype | 2017 | Stories-style Highlights | Removed in 2018 | Not disclosed |
| Snapchat | 2018 | Friends and Discover split | Petition of 1.2 million; kept | Shares down 6% in a day; first fall in daily users |
| 2018 | Sideways feed test | Apology; rolled back the same day | None reported | |
| X (Twitter) | 2023 | New name and logo | Not reversed | Analysts: $4–20 billion brand value at stake |
| Sonos | 2024 | Rebuilt app | CEO apology; CEO left in January 2025 | Fix: $20–30 million; two launches delayed |
From the reports and company statements listed under Sources, checked on 4 November 2026. Figures are as reported at the time, in US dollars. Share prices and revenue move for many reasons at once, so the figures show what happened around each change, not what the change alone caused.
Nine redesigns, and the apologies that followed
Every company on this list had a reason to change. Sonos needed a new app to launch its first headphones. Snapchat split its app into a page for friends and a feed for everything else. Digg rebuilt its entire platform, and Skype rebuilt its app around a feature borrowed from Snapchat. Each change was planned, designed and launched with confidence by a company that knew its product better than anyone.
What happened next follows a pattern. Users noticed what was missing before they noticed what was new, said so in public, and in most cases the company gave way: it apologised, brought the old version back or spent months rebuilding what it had removed. The table above gives each case in one line. The sections below start with the most recent and most expensive, and they do not claim that a redesign caused every number next to it.
Sonos (2024): an app, an apology and a new CEO
On 7 May 2024 Sonos replaced its app with a rebuilt one, released to every customer at once. It needed the new app for the launch of its first headphones, the Ace, because the old app and its cloud setup could not support them. The new version arrived without features people had used for years, among them alarms, editing the queue and playlists, and browsing and searching a local music library. Bloomberg later reported that employees had protested that the app was not ready; Sonos’s lead counsel told it that the list of bugs considered essential before launch "was not comprehensive enough".
On 25 July the CEO, Patrick Spence, published a letter in which he wanted "to begin by personally apologizing for disappointing you." On 7 August Sonos put the cost of fixing the app at $20 million to $30 million, and held back two products it had planned to launch that quarter until the app was fixed. The same day it cut its guidance for the year, saying the problems customers had with the new app required it, and Spence called the episode "one chapter in our over twenty years of delighting customers".
In October Sonos extended the warranty on its home speakers by a year, and its executive team said it would take no annual bonus for the following year unless the app and customer trust improved. Revenue for the fiscal year to September 2024 came in at $1.518 billion, 8.3% lower than the year before. On 13 January 2025 Spence stepped down, and a board member, Tom Conrad, took over as interim CEO; in a letter to employees, Conrad said the company had let its customers down with the May release.
Snapchat (2018): 1.2 million signatures and one tweet
Snap announced its redesign in November 2017 and rolled it out from the start of 2018. The new app separated a Friends page from a Discover feed, and moved things people had found by habit. On 10 January a user started a Change.org petition titled "Remove the new Snapchat Update"; it now shows 1,248,780 supporters. Snap replied on the petition page, "We hear you, and appreciate that you took the time to let us know how you feel," and kept the redesign.
In the week of 19 February Citigroup downgraded Snap’s stock to sell, citing the backlash against the redesign. On 21 February Kylie Jenner tweeted: "Sooo does anyone else not open Snapchat anymore? Or is it just me... ugh this is so sad." The next day Snap’s shares fell as much as 8% during trading and closed about 6% lower, a loss in market value reported at about $1.3 billion. Jenner followed up with "Still love you tho snap ... my first love."
In August 2018 Snap reported the first fall in daily users in its history, from 191 million to 188 million in a quarter. Evan Spiegel, its CEO, put it down mainly to the disruption caused by the redesign, and said the company was working to improve the app based on feedback from the community.
Digg v4 (2010): the redesign that sent its users to Reddit
In January 2010 Digg had 29.1 million monthly visitors, by comScore’s count, and was one of the largest news sites on the web. In August it launched version 4, which its founder Kevin Rose described as a major overhaul of the entire platform. It shipped with bugs, and it reduced the influence the most active users had over what reached the front page. At the end of August those users protested by voting up stories from Reddit’s Digg account until they filled the top of Digg; Reddit said the day brought it about 250,000 visits from Digg and around 9,000 new users.
A month after the launch Hitwise measured US visits to Digg down 26% and UK visits down 34%. Its analyst’s summary was "don’t alienate your core users." By May 2012 comScore counted 7.3 million monthly visitors to Digg, while Reddit had grown from 1.7 million in January 2010 to 9.2 million. In July 2012 Digg was sold to Betaworks, for $500,000 according to the Wall Street Journal, though Digg’s CEO said the overall consideration was "significantly larger". Four years earlier Google had reportedly looked at buying it for about $200 million.
Tropicana (2009) and Gap (2010): the carton and the logo
Tropicana is not a website, but it is the case every redesign brief should mention. In early 2009 it replaced the picture on its carton, an orange with a straw in it, with a glass of juice, in a design by Peter Arnell. Between 1 January and 22 February unit sales fell 20% and dollar sales 19%, according to figures reported by Ad Age. At the end of February Tropicana went back to the old carton, and a study for the Florida Department of Citrus later put the cost of the episode at an estimated $27 million.
Gap’s change was smaller and its retreat faster. In early October 2010 it replaced its decades-old blue box logo with a new one set in Helvetica. About a week later, on the evening of 11 October, Marka Hansen, president of Gap North America, announced: "All roads were leading us back to the blue box." She added that there might be a time to evolve the logo, and if it came, "we’ll handle it in a different way." Gap has not said what the week cost.
Facebook News Feed (2006): the backlash that was wrong
In September 2006 Facebook launched News Feed, a running list of what your friends were doing on the site. More than 500,000 users signed an online petition against it within days. Mark Zuckerberg’s first reply began "Calm down. Breathe. We hear you." By 8 September he had written "We really messed this one up" and "This was a big mistake on our part, and I’m sorry for it," and Facebook had added privacy settings that let people choose what appeared in their friends’ feeds.
What Facebook apologised for was the missing control, not the feature. News Feed stayed, and it became the main way people use Facebook. It is the case that keeps this list honest: a backlash does not prove a redesign was wrong. It proves that people were surprised, and that something they cared about, in this case their privacy, had been changed without asking them.
Skype (2017) and Instagram (2018): a borrowed feature and a test that escaped
In June 2017 Skype redesigned its app around Highlights, a feature for photos and videos that disappeared after 24 hours, much like Stories on Snapchat. In September 2018 Microsoft removed it. Peter Skillman, Skype’s director of design, explained: "This past year we explored some design changes and heard from customers that we overcomplicated some of our core scenarios. Calling became harder to execute and ‘Highlights’ didn’t resonate with a majority of users." For a calling app, calling had become harder. Microsoft retired Skype altogether on 5 May 2025 and moved its users to Teams, a decision it explained as streamlining its free communication products.
On 27 December 2018 Instagram showed a large number of users a feed they tapped through sideways instead of scrolling. It was meant to be a small test. Adam Mosseri, the head of Instagram, answered the complaints with "Sorry for the confusion! Always trying new ideas, usually with a much smaller number of people," and a spokesperson called it a bug: "We quickly fixed the issue and feed is back to normal. We apologize for any confusion." It was rolled back the same day, and it is the cheapest case on this list for a simple reason: the old version was still one switch away.
Twitter to X (2023): the rebrand that stayed
On 23 July 2023 Elon Musk and Twitter’s CEO, Linda Yaccarino, announced that Twitter would become X, and the next day the bird logo started to disappear from the site. Analysts and brand agencies quoted at the time put the value at stake at between $4 billion and $20 billion. The range was wide because the starting points were: Brand Finance valued the whole Twitter brand at about $4 billion, Vanderbilt University at $15 billion to $20 billion.
It is the biggest change on this list, nobody apologised for it, and there is no clean figure for what it cost. By Musk’s own account, advertising revenue had already fallen by more than half since he bought the company in October 2022, before the name changed. It belongs here as the other end of the scale: most of the other companies on this list changed far less than a name, and still gave way within weeks or months.
Why redesigns fail: four reasons, mostly in the companies’ own words
In most of these cases the complaint was not about how the new version looked, but about what it took away. Sonos removed alarms, queue editing and library search. Skype made calling harder. Digg took influence away from the users who filled its front page, and Gap and Tropicana took away a design people recognised without reading it. A redesign that only adds is rarely a problem; one that removes something people use every day is noticed on the first day.
The second reason is launching before the new version can do what the old one did. Sonos’s own counsel conceded that its list of essential pre-launch bugs "was not comprehensive enough", and Digg launched with bugs on top of the changes. The third is releasing to everyone at once with no way back: Sonos later called its May release an "all-at-once automated app release", and replaced it with a promise of gradual rollouts. The fourth is the one Hitwise put in four words after Digg: don’t alienate your core users. The people who complain loudest about a redesign are usually the ones who were happy before it.
None of this is limited to apps with millions of users. A company website loses visitors the same way after a relaunch, through missing pages, broken links and changed URLs; what a normal dip looks like, and when it should worry you, is in our timeline of traffic after a redesign. Whether you need a redesign at all is a separate question, covered in when to redesign your website.
What a safer redesign does
Sonos wrote the rule itself, five months too late: no more all-at-once releases. In October 2024 it promised that any major change to its app would be released gradually, that smaller new features would first come as an opt-in experiment, and that it would set quality benchmarks at the start of development and not launch before meeting them. Reddit had done the first part in 2018: its redesign went to a small, randomly chosen group of about 1% of users first, anyone could go back to the old design at old.reddit.com, and the company said it had no plans to do away with the old site.
For a business website the same rules make a short list. Write down everything the current site does, including the dull parts customers rely on, and do not launch until the new one does all of it. Keep every URL that ranks, or redirect it, as our guide to redesigning without losing SEO explains. Show the new version to part of your visitors first if you can, and compare it with the old one before you switch everyone. In a larger company, decide in advance who can stop the launch; our website redesign checklist for companies over €5M revenue covers that.
If you want a second opinion before you change anything, a UX Audit looks at how people use your current site and what they would miss. If the redesign is already decided, our Website Redesign package rebuilds the site with a new look and a new UX, and carries your rankings over.
— FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Sources
Every date, figure and quote above comes from one of these reports or company statements, all checked on 4 November 2026. Where reports differ, the text gives the more cautious figure and says whose it is.
- MacRumors — Sonos Apologizes for Widely Criticized App Redesign, Provides Progress Update ↗
25 July 2024: Patrick Spence’s apology; the app released on 7 May lacked playlist and queue editing, alarms, some settings and music library browse and search.
- Sonos — Sonos Reports Third Quarter Fiscal 2024 Results (SEC filing) ↗
7 August 2024: the problems caused by the new app required a reduction to fiscal 2024 guidance; Spence calls it "one chapter in our over twenty years of delighting customers".
- Engadget — Sonos is delaying two product launches until it fixes its buggy app ↗
7 August 2024: Spence puts the cost of fixing the app at $20–30 million; two launches planned for the quarter held until the app is fixed.
- MacRumors — Sonos Execs Launched Ill-Received App Despite Employee Protests ↗
23 September 2024, reporting Bloomberg: the app was rebuilt for the Ace headphones; employees protested; Sonos’s counsel says the list of essential bugs "was not comprehensive enough".
- Sonos Community — Our New Quality and Customer Experience Commitments ↗
1 October 2024: no more all-at-once releases, gradual rollout of major changes, opt-in experimental features, a year’s extra warranty, no executive bonus unless quality and trust improve.
- Sonos — Sonos Reports Fourth Quarter and Fiscal 2024 Results (SEC filing) ↗
13 November 2024: fiscal 2024 revenue of $1,518.1 million against $1,655.3 million the year before.
- CE Pro — Sonos CEO Patrick Spence Steps Down as Company Looks to Get Back on Track ↗
13 January 2025: Spence steps down; Tom Conrad interim CEO; Conrad tells employees the company let customers down with the May release.
- Change.org — Remove the new Snapchat Update ↗
Started 10 January 2018; 1,248,780 supporters; Snap’s reply on the page.
- CNBC — Kylie Jenner just wiped $1.7 billion off Snap’s market cap and the worst isn’t over for the stock ↗
22 February 2018: shares down as much as 8% during trading; Citigroup’s downgrade to sell that week, citing the redesign; redesign announced on 7 November 2017. The text itself gives no dollar figure.
- FOX 13 Seattle — Snapchat stock loses $1.3 billion after Kylie Jenner tweet ↗
22 February 2018: Jenner’s two tweets; shares closed down 6%, about $1.3 billion in market value; petition past 1.2 million.
- Engadget — Snapchat lost 3 million daily users in the past three months ↗
7 August 2018: daily users down from 191 million to 188 million, the first fall in Snap’s history, put down mainly to the redesign.
- The Next Web — Digg Sends Reddit 250,000 Hits And 9,000 New Users In A Day ↗
31 August 2010: Digg users fill the front page with Reddit links in protest; Reddit’s own figures.
- Computerworld — Users drop Digg after unpopular redesign ↗
28 September 2010: Hitwise measures US visits down 26% and UK visits down 34% since the end of August; "don’t alienate your core users".
- MIT Technology Review — Why Did Reddit Succeed Where Digg Failed? ↗
18 July 2012, comScore: Digg 29.1 million monthly visitors in January 2010, 7.3 million in May 2012; Reddit 1.7 million to 9.2 million.
- SmartCompany — Digg reportedly sold to Betaworks for just $500,000 ↗
13 July 2012: the Wall Street Journal’s $500,000 figure, Digg’s CEO saying the consideration was larger, and Google’s reported interest at about $200 million in 2008.
- Fortune — Tropicana reignited a 15-year feud with customers over its packaging design, slimming down bottles ↗
19 November 2024: the 2009 carton by Peter Arnell; unit sales down 20% and dollar sales down 19% from 1 January to 22 February, per Ad Age.
- Florida Department of Citrus — A Study of the Impact of Tropicana’s Marketing Strategy Changes on OJ Demand ↗
Jonq-Ying Lee: the redesign cost an estimated $27 million; the old package returned at the end of February 2009.
- Adweek — Gap ditches new logo, returns to its old one ↗
October 2010: Marka Hansen’s statement, "All roads were leading us back to the blue box".
- The Christian Science Monitor — New Gap logo withdrawn: The ‘blue box’ lives on ↗
12 October 2010: the Helvetica logo withdrawn about a week after it appeared; "we’ll handle it in a different way".
- The Register — Facebook mods controversial ‘stalker-friendly’ feature ↗
8 September 2006: more than 500,000 users signed a petition; Zuckerberg’s apology and the new privacy controls.
- Fortune — Facebook’s News Feed Rocked the News Headlines 10 Years Ago ↗
6 September 2016: "Calm down. Breathe. We hear you."; News Feed is now the main way users interact on Facebook.
- CNBC — Microsoft’s Skype gets a redesign, ditching Snapchat-like feature ‘Highlights’ ↗
3 September 2018: Highlights, introduced in June 2017, removed; Peter Skillman’s explanation.
- Microsoft 365 Blog — The next chapter: Moving from Skype to Microsoft Teams ↗
28 February 2025: Skype available until 5 May 2025; users moved to Teams.
- TheWrap — Instagram boss apologizes after users flip out over accidental horizontal swipe update ↗
27 December 2018: Adam Mosseri’s replies and Instagram’s statement calling it a bug.
- TIME — By Turning Twitter Into X, Elon Musk Risks Killing Billions in Brand Value ↗
25 July 2023: rebrand announced 23 July; $4–20 billion estimates; Brand Finance and Vanderbilt valuations; advertising revenue down more than 50% since October 2022, per Musk.
- Engadget — Reddit’s first redesign in years is a major one ↗
3 April 2018: the redesign goes to 1% of users first; users can keep the old interface.
- Fox News (Digital Trends) — Reddit refurbishes its bland style, adds an endless scroll, new view options ↗
4 April 2018: a random small group first; opt-out through old.reddit.com; no plans to do away with the current site.
Planning a redesign?
We start from what your current site does well and what your customers use, keep it, and change the rest, with your URLs and rankings carried over.